We Are Not All Right BY: BOAZ MICHAEL
Heartfelt musical responses from Five for Fighting and U2 to the October 7 attacks are timely, moving, and strengthening.
In times of rising anti-Zionism and anti-Semitism, solidarity from the nations holds a special significance for us in Israel and for the worldwide Jewish community. I found two recent examples especially touching: musical tributes from U2 and Five for Fighting. These expressions of solidarity from renowned non-Jewish artists are not just sources of comfort; they are essential affirmations of support in a world where anti-Semitism and opposition to Israel are alarmingly prevalent.
Platinum-selling, Grammy-nominated singer-songwriter John Ondrasik, better known as Five for Fighting, released the powerful song “OK” on December 14, 2023. It resonates deeply, offering a reflection of our collective grief and determination. The lyrics of the song speak to the heart of the challenges faced by our community, underscoring the need for unity and resilience in times of adversity. Ondrasik’s words, “We are not all right … This is a time for choosing … This is a time to mourn … The moral man is losing …” overlaying images of the October 7 atrocities, the rocket rise of woke pro-Palestine advocates, raging global anti-Semitism, glorification of Hamas’ aspirations of genocide, and the normalization of Jew-hatred—it’s a powerful combination that moves the heart. He lends his powerful voice to our shared experiences of mourning and the ongoing struggle for justice.
U2’s tribute on October 8th is equally raw and impactful. Lead singer Bono’s dedication of “Pride (In the Name of Love)” to the victims of the Nova Festival, performed during their Las Vegas performance, is a profound gesture of empathy and solidarity. Choking up, his words from the heart on stage encapsulate the complex emotions of the moment—a blend of sorrow, anger, and a steadfast commitment to peace. He said, “In the light of what’s happened in Israel and Gaza, a song about non-violence seems somewhat ridiculous, even laughable, but our prayers have always been for peace and for non-violence.” He continued, “But our hearts and our anger, you know where that’s pointed. So sing with us … and those beautiful kids at that music festival.” https://youtu.be/P6sD5Lnh4YY
These artistic responses by Five for Fighting and U2 are significant not only for their emotional depth but also for their role in counteracting the narratives of anti-Semitism and anti-Zionism. In a climate where biases and misconceptions often obscure reality, such influential voices help to bring clarity and advocate for understanding and justice.
I wept when I saw both of these songs for the first time, and even watching them again and again still moves me deeply. These songs are more than artistic expressions; they are reminders that within the global community, there are voices that recognize and stand against the injustices faced by our people.
They reinforce the message that amidst the challenges, we are not alone in our journey toward peace and harmony.